BYBONNIE J. CRAIG, Dip.D.H., M.Ed., RDH, Director, and
LISA SUPEENE, Dip.D.H., RDH, 3rd Year BDSc Student
As primary oral health care providers, dental hygienists often
Dental Hygiene Degree Completion (BDSc) Program
provide information about dental treatments and procedures
Faculty of Dentistry, University of British Columbia
to the public. Dental tooth whitening is a subject about which
many people seek information and advice, so it is important
KEY WORDS: tooth bleaching/efficacy/adverse effects;
for dental hygienists to possess current and accurate knowl-
hydrogen peroxide/toxicity, tooth whitening: efficacy, effects
edge about tooth whitening products and procedures. This
article provides information from the scientific literature that
will help dental hygienists field questions and promote careful
ABSTRACTPersonal appearance is important in today’s society. Many
A MedLine search over a 25-year period was conducted. This
products and procedures, including tooth whitening, are
paper provides a literature review that examines the efficacy of
being marketed to the public as a method for enhancing
tooth bleaching and its effects on hard and soft oral tissues,
personal appearance. People frequently ask dental profes-
the psychological impact of dental aesthetics, the impact of
sionals whether tooth whitening is effective and whether
bleaching agents on selected restorative materials, and possi-
it would be appropriate treatment for them. In order to
ble health issues surrounding tooth whitening.
field the public’s questions and promote informed choices,
dental hygienists must be knowledgeable about tooth whit-
A MedLine search over a 25-year period was conducted to
Personal appearance is very important in society. Dentists are
locate studies about the efficacy, effects and biological safety
called upon to respond to requests from patients who wish to
of tooth whitening products and procedures. The search
enhance their smiles.1 The effect of a smile can be so significant
resulted in approximately 60 articles. Additional articles
that advertising experts refer to this phenomenon as “smile power”.2
were obtained through article references. The objective of
the research was to prepare a literature review on tooth
Social and psychological research has shown that appearance
plays an important role in determining the quality of our inter-
actions with others and is an important aspect of nonverbal
The literature revealed that teeth can be bleached approxi-
communication.2,3 How people look can affect how they see
mately two shades but a second follow-up treatment is usu-
themselves, what others think of them, and how they attract
ally required after one to three years. In-office and at-home
others to them. By enhancing their appearance, people can
bleaching techniques were studied. Bleaching materials
change the impression they make on others. Physical attrac-
were found to adversely affect dental hard tissues. Some
tiveness and self-evaluation have been positively correlated.2,3
evidence was provided to support the view that short-term
effects of tooth whitening on tooth pulps appear to be re-
Research has shown that throughout their lives attractive indi-
versible. Long-term effects of bleaching agents on hard and
viduals have significant advantages over those perceived by
soft tissues remain unknown. Evidence shows there is a
reduction in enamel-composite resin bond strength in teeth
treated with peroxide agents though the clinical signifi-
The influence of cosmetics in promoting psychological well-
cance of this bond reduction is not known. Safety issues
being and to the importance of self-perceived attractiveness is
concerning the impact of peroxide agents on human oral
beginning to be recognized and understood in health care. Stud-
mucosal antioxidant defense mechanisms were identified.
ies have shown that when increased attention is placed on
appearance, patients’ adjustments to illness and recuperation
The writers’ research found little consensus in much of
times are affected positively.3 In dentistry, Jenny et al. con-
the research. A number of significant areas of concern have
firmed that dental esthetics impact on the perceived levels of
not yet been thoroughly investigated. Long-term scientific
self-confidence in assessments of personality characteristics.4
human studies are recommended to address the unan-
Cosmetic dentistry appears to be emerging as a health service.
swered questions about the efficacy, effects and biological
Researchers agree that more investigation into psychological
factors associated with appearance is needed.
P R O B E S C I E N T I F I C J O U R N A L n N O V E M B E R / D E C E M B E R 1 9 9 9 n V O L U M E 3 3 , N U M B E R 6
flat appearance that is not aesthetically pleasing. Some tetra-
cycline stains may appear lighter after bleaching but do not
become whiter. Researchers agree that brown-orange and yel-
To date the process of stain formation is not well understood.
low tooth stains in older adults bleach the fastest and easiest
Pellicle-coated enamel is known to have a net negative charge,
though similarly coloured stains in teens and young adults do
so permitting selective adhesion of positive ions to tooth
not respond as well. Blue-gray stains are significantly more
surfaces. This is believed to play a critical role in the deposi-
difficult to eliminate. Moderate to dark stains, and those caused
tion of stains on tooth surfaces.5 It seems likely that ions from
by tetracycline, have been found to be the least likely to
food and drink containing tannins as well as chromogens such
respond.8 Reports indicate that vital night guard bleaching
as copper, nickel, and iron, attach to the negative charge on
techniques can achieve acceptable esthetic results.12–16 The
the pellicle-coated enamel, causing dental stains.
effects of both at-home and in-office bleaching are unlikely to
be permanent. Follow-up treatments have often been found to
The mechanism of action of bleaching is also unclear. Bleach-
be necessary in between one and three years.12–16
ing is an oxidation reaction. The enamel to be bleached
donates electrons to the bleaching agent.2 Ten per cent car-
bamide peroxide breaks down to 3% hydrogen peroxide and
7% urea. The hydrogen peroxide metabolizes into water and
free radicals of oxygen. These free radicals possess a single
To date, studies examining the adverse effect of peroxides on
electron, which is thought to combine with the chromagens
the microhardness of dental hard tissues have shown conflict-
ing results. Rotstein et al. subjected human premolars to solu-
tions of 30% hydrogen peroxide, 10% carbamide peroxide,
sodium perborate, and three commercially-prepared bleach-
ing agents (utilizing 10-15% carbamide peroxide with pH
ranges from 6.0 to 6.5).17 Results showed that most of the
Documented reports on the efficacy and prognosis of tooth
bleaching agents caused changes in the levels of calcium, phos-
whitening consist largely of clinical and anecdotal observa-
phorus, sulfur, and potassium in the hard tissues. Alterations
tions. There is a lack of consensus among researchers about
in the inorganic components of hydroxyapatite are the result
the results of in-office and at-home tooth bleaching.6,7 Haywood
of changes in the calcium/phosphorus ratio found within the
and Heymann were the first to report on the procedures and
hydroxyopatite crystals of dental hard tissues. The decrease
results of an at-home vital tooth bleaching system utilizing
was more significant in cementum and dentin than in enamel.
night guards and 10% carbamide peroxide.8 This technique
This was in all likelihood due to differences between the or-
resulted in a lightening the teeth by the shade guide equiva-
ganic and inorganic matter of the tooth. It was concluded that
lent of approximately two shades. No detrimental effects on
bleaching materials may adversely affect dental hard tissues.
the teeth or gingiva were observed and no significant tissue
problems, odour or bad taste were reported. Prior to Hayward
Lewinstein et al. also studied the microhardness of human
and Heymann’s report, in-office bleaching techniques were
enamel and dentin.18 Thirty per cent hydrogen peroxide was
most commonly used. The in-office technique involved acid
used at 37oC and 50oC. This study found a reduction in the
etching the enamel with 37% phosphoric acid. This was
microhardness of enamel and dentin. The hardness reduction
followed by the application of 30–35% hydrogen peroxide
was time-related and results were statistically significant on
applied with supplementary heat using a specially designed
dentin following a five-minute treatment and on enamel after
lamp or a contact instrument. The literature records that in-
a fifteen-minute treatment (p<0.05). Researchers suggested
office bleaching appears to be preferred by dentists because
that the use of high concentrations of hydrogen peroxide should
the procedure can be more readily controlled and monitored.
However, at-home bleaching has become increasingly popu-
Shannon et al. evaluated the effect of three 10% carbamide
lar because it is easy to use, time-saving and cost-effective.9–11
peroxide bleaching agents with different pH values on enamel
There is well documented evidence that shows the
microhardness and surface morphology following 16 hours of
unpredictability of tooth bleaching results. The degree of whit-
daily exposure for two and four weeks.19 Unlike other studies,
ening or lightening that can be achieved, the length and
this was a combined in vitro and in vivo study. Results indi-
number of treatments required, the type of stain that will
cated that there were no statistically significant differences
respond, and how long the results of bleaching last, are diffi-
between the microhardness values of the subject and control
cult to predict. Bleaching tooth stain that requires prolonged
groups at two weeks or at four weeks, although hardness
treatment may result in a whiter but chalkier, rather dull and
values of subjects were less than those of controls. There was
an increase in microhardness at four weeks, which may have
P R O B E S C I E N T I F I C J O U R N A L n N O V E M B E R / D E C E M B E R 1 9 9 9 n V O L U M E 3 3 , N U M B E R 6
resulted from exposure of the enamel to artificial saliva.
to the findings of Cohen.21 This may be explained by differ-
Remineralization potential exists with saliva substitutes con-
ences between canine and human teeth. The two studies agree
taining calcium and phosphate ions. Scanning electron
that the observed pulpal changes were reversible. Although
microscopy showed differences in surface topography of enamel
clinical observations and scientific literature report short-term,
treated with bleaching solutions. These changes were observed
minimal hypersensitivity to in-office and at-home bleaching
in surfaces treated with the lower pH carbamide peroxide agents
treatments, there have been studies published that raise con-
and appeared as pitting and/or enamel erosion. Enamel
cerns about possible harmful effects of some bleaching agents
remineralization resulting from exposure to saliva may modify
Glucose metabolism and protein synthesis, especially collagen
Attin et al. observed an initial significant loss of enamel
synthesis, are the two most central metabolic processes occur-
microhardness after bleaching.20 Rehardening of the enamel
ring in the pulp. These metabolic reactions are catalyzed by
after treatment was attributed to the remineralization capacity
enzymes that are sensitive to changes in environmental condi-
of saliva. Furthermore, results showed a decrease in enamel
tions.29 Bowles and Thompson examined combined effects of
surface hardness in those samples treated with highly concen-
heat and hydrogen peroxide on pulpal enzymes and found that
most of the enzymes were relatively resistant to the effects of
heat up to 50oC. 27 However, nearly every enzyme tested was
inhibited to some degree by hydrogen peroxide. At concentra-
tions as low as 5% some enzymes were completely inactivated.
Studies have been conducted to examine the penetration of
Results indicated that a combination of heat and hydrogen per-
hydrogen peroxide and carbamide peroxide into the pulp
oxide might increase the permeability of the pulp and potentiate
chambers of teeth. Human and canine studies showed that
the effects of hydrogen peroxide on the pulp. While the pulp
both low (10%) and high (35%) concentrations of bleaching
appears to be quite resilient, there is concern for patients who
agents readily penetrate the pulp chamber.21-24
may apply bleaching agents for longer periods of time or more
frequently than recommended in order to hasten the achieve-
Cohen applied 35% hydrogen peroxide and heat for 30-minute
ment of whiter teeth. The long-term effects of frequent or pro-
sessions to human teeth due to be removed for orthodontic
longed use of bleaching agents on pulps are unknown.26–29
treatment.21 Varying degrees of sensitivity, lasting from 24–48
hours, were reported by 78% of the subjects. Twenty-two per
The reasons for tooth sensitivity during vital tooth bleaching
cent reported no sensitivity. Histological findings in both the
are not clear. Studies are inconclusive regarding the pulpal
experimental and control groups showed that, except for
considerations of vital tooth bleaching. What is clear, how-
moderate vasodilation and aspiration of odontoblast nuclei into
ever, is that case selection is critical. Considerations prior to
the dental tubules, all pulps were normal. There were no
initiating tooth whitening procedures should include assess-
histological findings to explain the sensitivity experienced by
ment of the condition of existing restorations, cervical erosion,
the subjects. A possible explanation may be that pressure builds
enamel cracks, and the estimated duration and repetition of
in the pulp chamber as a result of the heat applied, causing
bleaching required to obtain and maintain the desired effect.30
the sensation of pain. The sensitivity, moderate vasodilation
and aspiration of odontoblasts into the dental tubules appeared
Seale exposed the canine teeth of dogs to 35% hydrogen per-
oxide with and without heat.23 The control teeth either received
While there is a record in the literature of in-office and at-
heat only or had no treatment at all. Histological examinations
home tooth bleaching, many questions remain unanswered re-
following exposure were conducted at 3, 15, and 60 days.
garding the effects of bleaching agents on both tooth struc-
Application of heat only caused some vasodilation in the
tures and restorative materials and procedures.31 The literature
canine tooth pulps but no other pulpal changes. The applica-
is consistent in demonstrating a reduction in the enamel-com-
tion of hydrogen peroxide with and without heat caused some
posite resin bond strength in teeth previously treated with some
initial severe pulpal changes that included obliteration of
form of peroxide agent.31–34 Disagreement occurs with respect
odontoblasts, hemorrhage, inflammation and internal
to the duration of this reduction, ways to reverse this effect,
resorption of dentin. The 60-day histological examination
and the clinical significance, if any, of the reduced bond strength.
showed only a few changes in otherwise normal pulps.
Apparently the pulps were able to recover within that time.
Dishman et al. studied the effects of 25% hydrogen peroxide
The severity of pulpal change reported by Seale is in contrast
on human teeth.31 Results showed a reduction in enamel-
P R O B E S C I E N T I F I C J O U R N A L n N O V E M B E R / D E C E M B E R 1 9 9 9 n V O L U M E 3 3 , N U M B E R 6
composite bond strength that was time dependent. Although
be limited to the surface of the enamel and may not be a factor
reductions in bond strength appeared to last less than 24 hours,
if the surface layer of the enamel is removed following bleach-
bond strength tested one month after bleaching was signifi-
ing. This procedure is thought to be effective since polymeri-
cantly lower in the group that was bonded one week after
zation of bonding agents is known to be inhibited by oxygen.
bleaching than in the control group. This evidence indicates
If the oxygen-rich surface layer of enamel is removed, the resin-
that there may be a longer-term effect on the enamel-compos-
enamel bond strength returns to near normal. The exact depth
ite bond strength from bleaching. The significance of this is
of this layer is not known, but must be greater than 5–10
microns, otherwise the acid etching prior to bonding would
remove this oxygen-rich layer of enamel.31
Titley et al. reported a statistically significant reduction in bond
strength in bovine teeth following treatment with 35% hydro-
gen peroxide.32 They also showed that the reduction in bond
strength could be moderated to varying degrees by water
immersion following exposure to the bleaching agent. How-
Methods of tooth whitening have existed for more than 100
ever, the immersion time required to totally eliminate the
years.35 During the last decade increased attention to techniques
effect on bond strength was undetermined.
of bleaching has raised safety concerns.36 The review by
Goldstein and Kiremidjian-Schumacher found 246 citations by
Titley et al. studied the effect of 10% carbamide peroxide at
cross-referencing hydrogen peroxide with toxicity.36 There are
pH 4.7 and 7.2 on bovine teeth.33 The purpose of the study
safety concerns associated with the potential biological effects
was to test whether the less concentrated peroxide (10%
of free radicals, specifically free radicals of oxygen, that are
carbamide peroxide) commonly used in most at-home tooth-
by-products or intermediates of hydrogen peroxide metabo-
whitening products yielded the same effect as previous stud-
lism.35 A search of the literature shows a lack of any conclu-
ies utilizing 35% hydrogen peroxide. The results of the shear
sive findings and often contradictions about the toxicity of
bond strength tests revealed a statistically significant differ-
hydrogen peroxide. The oxidative process is thought to be
ence (p<0.01). There were no statistically significant differ-
associated with the development of carcinogens, aging, stroke,
ences due to exposure time (3 hours vs. 6 hours) or pH (4.7 vs.
liver disease, and other degenerative diseases.35–39 Although
7.2). Although this study demonstrated a reduction of shear
hydrogen peroxide has been in widespread use for many years
bond strength due to exposure to 10% carbamide peroxide,
as an antiseptic in the healing of wounds, as a whitening agent
the reduction in bond strength was substantially less than where
for teeth, and as an adjunct in periodontal therapy in combi-
35% hydrogen peroxide was used. The investigators stated that
nation with salt and/or sodium bicarbonate, concerns persist
the results are not conclusive regarding the clinical significance
of the reduction of enamel adhesive strength due to exposure
to 10% carbamide peroxide products. They did recommend a
The most common side-effects of tooth bleaching techniques
delay of at least 24 hours for restorative treatment following
are transient thermal sensitivity and oral irritation or ulcera-
any bleaching procedures using peroxide-based agents.
tion.30,40,41 A few reported cases have shown severe reactions
to vital tooth bleaching.24,25 The greater concern for safety re-
Stokes et al. conducted shear bond strength tests on human
lates to the subtle biological reactions that take place rather
teeth treated with 35% hydrogen peroxide and 10% carbamide
than the clinically observable reactions.
peroxide.34 It was determined that the shear bond strengths of
resin-enamel bonds following treatment with both types of
There is an oxygen paradox in aerobic life. While oxygen is
peroxide were significantly lower than the controls. The use of
essential for higher life forms, it is also toxic to all aerobes
lower concentration carbamide peroxide (10%) posed similar
under certain conditions.36,39 During respiration, humans
hazards to resin bonding as with the 35% hydrogen peroxide.
metabolize oxygen into water. In this metabolic process, chemi-
cal reactions occur that result in the formation of water and
Researchers explain the reduction in the adhesive strength of
by-products. A small fraction (2–5%) of the total oxygen con-
the peroxide-treated enamel as the interactions occurring at
sumed by all humans is diverted and forms semi-reduced forms
the resin-enamel interface. There is evidence of voids in the
of oxygen. These “activated oxygen species” are generally
bonding resin possibly caused by gaseous bubbles resulting
unstable, very reactive, and will act as chain carriers in chemi-
from the oxidizing reaction of peroxide entrapped in the sub-
cal reactions. At least three such chemical species are involved
surface layer of the enamel. Elimination of the trapped perox-
in oxygen free radical damage in biological systems: hydrogen
ide, achieved by leaching in water, may cause an increase in
peroxide, superoxide, and the hydroxyl free radical.37,39
adhesive strength of the enamel surface.32,33 Decrease in adhe-
Superoxide and hydrogen peroxide participate in oxidative
sive strength following various bleaching regimens appears to
reactions, which damage lipids, proteins and nucleic acids.37
P R O B E S C I E N T I F I C J O U R N A L n N O V E M B E R / D E C E M B E R 1 9 9 9 n V O L U M E 3 3 , N U M B E R 6
All tissues are constantly subjected to oxidative stress because
tabolism of hydrogen peroxide yields oxygen free radicals. These
they exist in an aerobic or oxygen-rich environment. Nature
free radicals are very reactive and mobile. If they are able to
has created enzymes (SOD, catalase, peroxidase) and antioxi-
gain access to connective tissue, the free radicals may adversely
dants (ascorbate, vitamin E, glutathione) which help the body
affect gingival fibroblasts and their ability to maintain the tis-
defend against the effects of oxidation. Biological systems
sue and participate in healing.42 Just how susceptible tissue is
exist in a state of dynamic equilibrium where the antioxidant
to oxidative stress depends on the magnitude of the stress and
defense capacity counteracts the oxidative damage potential.
the antioxidant status of the tissue. A pre-existing tissue in-
When the antioxidative capacity of the system is overwhelmed,
jury, chronic inflammation or the concurrent use of alcohol
and/or tobacco while using tooth whiteners may exacerbate
their toxic effects.40,42–44 Animal studies have raised the issue
Weitzman et al. investigated the effects of 3% and 30% hydro-
of potential health concerns related to prolonged hydrogen per-
gen peroxide alone and in combination with a known carcino-
oxide use.45 Overt signs of hydrogen peroxide toxicity in dental
gen, DMBA (9,10-dimethyl-1,2-benzanthracene, an analogue
tooth whitening have not been recognized and researchers have
to a known ingredient in tobacco).40 Four hydrogen peroxide
yet to definitively determine the long-term effects of hydrogen
solutions were applied topically to the buccal mucosa of
peroxide when used in tooth bleaching agents.
Syrian hamsters twice a week for 22 weeks. All animals treated
with 30% hydrogen peroxide alone exhibited hyperkeratosis
and hyperplasia, and four of nine revealed hyperchromatic cells
and mild dysplasia. In animals treated with DMBA alone, three
What is evident from a review of the literature is the lack of
of seven developed epidermoid carcinoma. Six of eleven ani-
consensus in much of the research. Many areas of concern
mals treated with DMBA together with 3% hydrogen peroxide
have not yet been thoroughly investigated. It is well-docu-
and all animals treated with DMBA plus 30% hydrogen perox-
mented that teeth can be bleached. Most authors conclude
ide developed carcinomas. It was concluded that long-term
that retreatment is necessary but disagree on the intervals of
exposure to hydrogen peroxide can itself induce pathologic
time between treatments with reports ranging form one to
changes and may augment the oral carcinogenesis associated
three years. Transient clinical side-effects such as thermal
with DMBA. It is not known if exposure to hydrogen peroxide
sensitivity and mucosal irritation have been reported. Bleach-
from tooth bleaching can deplete or overwhelm human oral
ing agents exert some changes in hard and soft oral tissues
mucosal antioxidant defense mechanisms. Although animal
and in restorative materials, although it is uncertain if these
studies cannot be generalized to humans, these results sug-
changes are clinically significant. The short-term effects on
gest that caution should be exercised especially in concomi-
dental hard tissues and pulpal tissues appear to be reversible.
tant use of tooth bleaching agents containing hydrogen perox-
Questions about the frequent and/or long-term use of bleach-
ide for patients who are tobacco users.
ing agents and their impact on dental hard tissues, pulpal
Rees and Orth reported that 3% hydrogen peroxide delayed
tissues and oral soft tissues remain. Hydrogen peroxide agents
the healing of wounds, caused leukoplakia, ulcerations on the
pose some health risk concerns when used in biological
tongue, alveolar, and labial mucosa, and eroded papillae.41
systems. The impact of hydrogen peroxide on human oral
Evidence suggests that hydrogen peroxide may be harmful to
mucosal antioxidant defense mechanisms is not yet completely
oral tissues even when used for short time periods, and that
understood. Long-term scientific human studies are needed.
with chronic use, injury may be more severe.
Because dental tooth whitening is likely to continue to be an
There is a strong association between oxygen free radicals and
available treatment option, dental hygienists can use the cur-
the development of cancer, although the exact mechanism is
rent literature to educate the public about the pros and cons
not well understood.38 Carcinogens develop in a two-step proc-
of tooth whitening agents and procedures. When bleaching
ess, initiation and promotion. Free radicals are thought to play
procedures are to be implemented, dental hygienists can
a role in both processes. During initiation, changes occur in
ensure that the client is a non-smoker with healthy periodon-
the genetic material of cells. DNA strand breakage is mediated
tium, has no cervical erosion or enamel cracks, and has intact
by active oxygen species such as hydrogen peroxide, which
restoration margins. Clients should be provided with custom-
damage specific amino acids in proteins. Initiated cells can
fitted bleaching trays with viscous bleaching gel and be
remain dormant. An influx of oxidative potential could possi-
advised to follow instructions very carefully. Clients should
bly promote already-initiated cells to express themselves.
be firmly reminded not to retain the trays with bleaching agent in
their mouths overnight while sleeping, nor to increase the amount
Dental tooth bleaching involves the use of various concentra-
of bleaching agent or the frequency of their use of bleaching agents
tions of hydrogen peroxide or carbamide peroxide. The me-
without first consulting a dental professional.
P R O B E S C I E N T I F I C J O U R N A L n N O V E M B E R / D E C E M B E R 1 9 9 9 n V O L U M E 3 3 , N U M B E R 6
23. Seale, N.S., McIntosh, J.E., Taylor, A.N.: Pulpal reaction to
bleaching of teeth in dogs. J Dent Res 60: pp. 948–953, 1981
1. Philip, D.S.: Incorporating cosmetic dentistry into a general
24. Seale, N.S., Wilson, C.F.: Pulpal response to bleaching of
practice. J Can Dent Assoc 60: pp. 682–686, 1994
teeth in dogs. Pediatr Dent 7: pp. 209–214, 1985
2. Goldstein, R.E.: Esthetic dentistry — a health service. J
25. Glickman, G.N., Frys, H., Baker, F.L.: Adverse response to
vital bleaching. J Endodontics 18: pp. 351–354, 1992
3. Graham, J.A., Jouhar, A.J.: The importance of cosmetics in
26. Zach, L, Cohen, G.: Pulp response to externally applied
the psychology of appearance. Int J of Dermatology 22: pp.
heat. Oral Surg 19: pp. 515–530, 1965
27. Bowles, W.H., Thompson, L.R.: Vital bleaching: the effect of
4. Jenny, J., Cons, N.C., Kohout, F.J., Jacobsen, J.R.: Relation-
heat and hydrogen peroxide on pulpal enzymes. J Endod 12:
ship between dental aesthetics and attributions of self-
confidence. J Dent Res 69: p. 204 Abstract # 761, 1990
28. Bowles, W.H., Ugwuneri, Z.: Pulp chamber penetration by
5. Nathoo, S.A.: The chemistry and mechanisms of extrinsic
hydrogen peroxide following vital bleaching procedures. J
and intrinsic discoloration. JADA 128: pp. 6S–9S, 1997
6. Goldstein, R.: Bleaching teeth. New materials — new role.
29. Cooper, J.S., Bokmeyer, T.J., Bowles, W.H.: Penetration of
JADA Special Issue: pp. 44E–52E, 1987
the pulp chamber by carbamide peroxide bleaching agents.
7. Nathanson, D., Parra, C.: Bleaching vital teeth: a review
and clinical study. Compend Contin Educ Dent 8: pp. 490–
30. Nathanson, D.: Vital tooth bleaching: sensitivity and pulpal
considerations. JADA 128: pp. 41S–44S, 1997
8. Haywood, V.B., Heymann, H.O.: Nightguard vital bleach-
31. Dishman, M.V., Covey, D.A., Baughan, L.W.: The effects of
ing. Quintessence Int 20: pp. 173–176, 1989
peroxide bleaching on composite to enamel bond strength.
9. Clinical Research Associates Newsletter. Provo, Utah:
32. Titley, K.C., Torneck, C.D., Ruse, N.D., Krmec, D.: Adhesion
10. Clinical Research Associates Newsletter. Provo, Utah:
of a resin composite to bleached and unbleached human
Clinical Research Associates, December 1989
enamel. J Endodontics 19: pp. 112–115, 1993
11. Clinical Research Associates Newsletter. Provo, Utah:
33. Titley, K.C., Torneck, C.D., Ruse, N.D.: The effect of carba-
Clinical Research Associates, December 1990
mide-peroxide gel on the shear bond strength of a microfilmResin to Bovine Enamel. J Dent Res 71: pp. 20–24, 1992
12. Feinman, R.A., Goldstein, R.E., Garber, D.A.: Bleaching
34. Stokes, A.N., Hood, J.A.A., Dhariwal, D., Patel, K.: Effect of
peroxide bleaches on resin-enamel bonds. Quintessence Int
13. Holmstrup, G., Palm, A.M., Lambjerg-Hansen, H.: Bleach-
ing of discolored root-filled teeth. Endodont Dent Traumatol4: 197–201, 1988
35. Li, L.: Toxicological considerations of tooth bleaching using
peroxide-containing agents. JADA 128: pp. 31S–35S, 1997
14. Friedman, S., Rothstein, I., Lihfeld, H., Stahholz, A., Heling,
I.: Incidence of external resorption and esthetic results in
36. Goldstein, G.R., Kiremidjian-Schumacher, L.: Bleaching: is it
58 bleached pulpless teeth. Endodont Dent Traumatol 4: pp.
safe and effective? J Prosth Dent 69: pp. 325–327, 1993
37. Floyd, R.A., Carney, J.M.: Free radical damage to protein
15. Walton, R.E., O’Dell, N.L., Myers, D., Lake, F.T., Shrimp,
and DNA: mechanisms involved and relevant observations
R.G.: External bleaching of tetracycline stained teeth in
on brain undergoing oxidative stress. Annals of Neurology
dogs. J Endodont 8: pp. 536–542, 1982
16. Meyers, D., O’Dell, N.L, Lake, F.T., Bell, R.A., Barenie, J.T.:
38. Varga, M.: Understanding the role of oxyradicals in general
The effectiveness of bleaching for the removal of tetracy-
and in toxic hepatic damage can help safer drug design.
cline from rat incisors. J Pedod 4: pp. 227–235, 1980
Medical Hypotheses 39: pp. 133–136, 1992
17. Rotstein, I., Dankner, E., Goldman, A., Heling, I., Stabholz,
39. Floyd, Robert A.: Role of oxygen free radicals in carcinogen-
A., Zalkind, M.: Histochemical analysis of dental hard
esis and brain ischemia. FASEB J 4: pp. 2587–2597, 1990
tissues following bleaching. J Endodontics 22: pp. 23–25,
40. Weitzman, S.A., Weitberg, A.B., Stossel, T.P., Schwartz, J.,
Shklar, G.: Effects of hydrogen peroxide on oral carcinogen-
18. Lewinstein, I., Hirschfeld, Z., Stabholz, A., Rotstein, I.:
esis in hamsters. J Perio 57: pp. 685–688, 1986
Effect of hydrogen peroxide and sodium perborate on the
41. Rees, T.D., Orth, C.F.: Oral ulcerations with use of hydrogen
microhardness of human enamel and dentin. J Endodontics
peroxide. J Perio 57: pp. 689–692, 1986
42. Tipton, D.A., Braxton, S.D., Dabbous, M.K.: Effects of a
19. Shannon, H., Spencer, P., Gross, K., Tira, D.: Characteriza-
bleaching agent on human gingival fibroblasts. J Perio 66:
tion of enamel exposed to 10% carbamide peroxide
bleaching agents. Quintessence Int 24: pp. 39–44, 1993
43. Weitzman, S.A., Weitberg, A.B., Nederman, R., Stossel, T.:
20. Attin, T., Kielbassa, A.M., Schwanenberg, M., Hellwig, E.:
Chronic treatment with hydrogen peroxide: is it safe? J Perio
Effect of fluoride treatment on remineralization of bleached
enamel. J Oral Rehab 24: pp. 282–286, 1997
44. Marshall, M.V., Cancro, L.P., Fischman, S.L.: Hydrogen
21. Cohen, S.C., Parkins, F.M.: Bleaching tetracycline-stained
peroxide: a review of its use in dentistry. J Perio 66: pp. 786–
vital teeth. Oral Surg Oral Med Oral Pathol 29: pp. 465–471,
45. Morris, A.L.: Factors influencing experimental carcinogen-
22. Cohen, S.C.: Human pulpal response to bleaching proce-
esis in the hamster check pouch. J Dent Res 40: pp. 3–14,
dures on vital teeth. J Endod 5: pp. 134–138, 1979
P R O B E S C I E N T I F I C J O U R N A L n N O V E M B E R / D E C E M B E R 1 9 9 9 n V O L U M E 3 3 , N U M B E R 6
Prevent unplanned pregnancies: help patients plan ahead and be prepared. Frequently asked questions for healthcare providers. How effective is Emergency Contraception? • Progestin-only Emergency Contraception Pills (ECPs) reduce the risk of pregnancy by 89%; • Combined ECPs, including both progestin and estrogen, reduce the chance of pregnancy by 74%; • A single
Topic Modeling for Discovering Drug-related Adverse Events from Social MediaMengjun Xie, PhD1, Jiang Bian, PhD2, Umit Topaloglu, PhD21University of Arkansas at Little Rock, 2University of Arkansas for Medical SciencesAbstractEarly detection of drug-related adverse events benefits both the drug regulators and manufacturers for pharmacovigi-lance.